All Columns in Alphabetical Order


Tuesday, June 13, 2023

Peachy Picks Second Location #271Amsterdam @madeinnypizza #MadeInNewYorkPizza by #ChrisGuilliani #UpperWestSide

This above pizza specifically is THE BEST PIZZA PEACHY HAS HAD ALL YEAR IN 2023
Peachy Deegan and Owner Chris Guilliani
It's not who you know it's WHOM YOU KNOW and we sure do know Made in New York Pizza.
Their first location at 421 Amsterdam at 80th earned them a laudable spot in Peachy's Picks earlier this year, and this second location is just as fabulous.  There are a lot of pizza places in New York, but they are not all created equally.  Some are just superior.
Looks like Sinatra agrees:
This 271 Amsterdam location was first featured last fall, and this second visit we decided to expand our horizons and be more adventurous because this brand has showed us they know what they are doing on basics.  What is better than drinking vodka?  Eating it on your pizza of course!  Check it out:
We chose roasted red peppers and eggplant to grace this beauty and the delicious vegetables were amazing!  Note that as we are nearly at bathing suit season we are eating accordingly but not TOO accordingly because we wear Miraclesuit!  From the crust to the quality vegetable ingredients that come to the party to the luxurious vodka sauce, this is a clearcut winner.  
Pizza glamour shots!
They are on a roll with winning reviews, but also quite literally when one considers the newest addition, the chicken roll!  Ready to frolic in marinara, this wonderful chicken breast is also highlighted by oregano and black pepper with mozzarella, naturally!  Delicious!
CANNONBALL!
From the Caesar Salad above to the House Salad below, Made in New York Pizza is consistent with produce quality and can be counted on to have the right nutritional balances in play!  They have the dressing on the side, exactly like we want.  Note we never edit pictures; it looks this fresh and premium in real life.
If you like Calzones, this is the place for you.  The Cheese Calzone is in a word, phenomenal.
The gooey mozzarella cheese is screaming it!
Also, Cassandra Stevens was a great professional to collaborate with this visit.
Finally, we could not more highly recommend the Fresh Mozzarella Margherita when you add what Peachy picked: spinach, onions and mushrooms!  This single pizza was simply THE BEST PIZZA WE HAVE HAD ALL YEAR.  Every ingredient was at its peak of nature, the crust was substantial enough to hold it but still fresh and chewy, and the sauce and cheese were absolutely divine yielding the best combination possible.
Made in New York Pizza has become a Peachy's Pick with their second Upper West Side location.
We look forward to seeing them keep up the excellence!






Back to TOP